Surgery Verdict — Trusted & unbiased second opinions

Cardiac & Cardiothoracic

Stent, bypass, or wait — the decision deserves a second reader

Cardiac recommendations swing on how an angiogram is read and how much of the heart muscle is still viable. A reviewer who operates weekly reads the same films and tells you, in writing, whether the proposed operation is the right one now.

Operations we review in this specialty

  • Coronary artery bypass grafting (CABG)
  • Angioplasty and stenting vs surgery
  • Aortic or mitral valve replacement or repair
  • Aortic aneurysm repair
  • Lung resection and thoracic procedures

1 in 4

cardiac reviews change the approach or its timing

Submit a cardiac case

Meet your reviewers

Specialists reviewing cardiac & cardiothoracic cases

You can request a preferred reviewer when you submit — your coordinator confirms availability before the service-level clock starts.

Watch first

What patients ask us most — answered by the panel

Short vertical answers from specialists who perform these operations. Read the written answer, or press play.

  • Panel answer

    My surgeon says bypass, another doctor said stents. Who is right?

    Video answer filming soon

    Dr. A. Menon
    Cardiothoracic surgeon · 19 yrs · 2,400+ cases

    Both can be right depending on how many vessels are involved, whether you are diabetic, and how your left ventricle is functioning. Multi-vessel disease with diabetes usually favours bypass for long-term survival; single-vessel disease often favours a stent. The honest answer comes from reading your angiogram, not from a general rule.

  • Panel answer

    Is it dangerous to wait 48 hours for a second opinion?

    Video answer filming soon

    Dr. A. Menon
    Cardiothoracic surgeon · 19 yrs · 2,400+ cases

    For stable angina and planned valve surgery, 48 hours changes nothing clinically. For an active heart attack, unstable chest pain at rest, or a dissection, you should not wait — go to emergency care. Our intake screens for exactly those situations and tells you to stop and seek treatment.

  • Panel answer

    Does it matter how many of these operations my surgeon does?

    Video answer filming soon

    Dr. A. Menon
    Cardiothoracic surgeon · 19 yrs · 2,400+ cases

    Yes, and it is one of the best-evidenced factors in cardiac surgery. Outcomes improve with both surgeon and hospital volume for valve repair and complex aortic work. Asking your surgeon how many they performed last year is a fair and normal question.

  • Panel answer

    What should I ask before consenting to heart surgery?

    Video answer filming soon

    Dr. A. Menon
    Cardiothoracic surgeon · 19 yrs · 2,400+ cases

    Ask what happens if you do nothing for three months, what the alternatives were and why they were rejected, your predicted risk score, how many of these the surgeon does yearly, and what recovery looks like week by week. A team that welcomes those questions is usually a good team.

The decisions a verdict actually settles

Repair or replace the valve

Repair preserves your own tissue and often avoids lifelong blood thinners, but not every valve is repairable and not every centre repairs routinely. Volume matters here more than almost anywhere in surgery.

How urgent is urgent

Some cardiac disease genuinely needs operating this week. Some can be optimised for a month with medication and rehabilitation, and the operation goes better for it. Those two situations look similar to a patient.

Number of grafts and approach

On-pump vs off-pump, single vs multiple grafts, and minimally invasive access all change recovery. A verdict states which approach the reviewer would choose and why.

Is it safe to ask?

Yes — and here is why

A second opinion is not disloyalty

Cardiac units expect it. Bringing an independent written verdict to your surgeon often improves the conversation, because it is specific and clinical rather than anxious and vague.

Your records stay yours

You are entitled to copies of your angiogram, echo and reports. You do not need your surgeon's permission to seek a review, and we never contact your treating team without your written instruction.

Your fee is held, not spent

Payment sits in escrow until a quality-checked verdict reaches you, and a service credit applies automatically if we miss the clock.

Do not wait for a review

Seek emergency care now if you have

  • Chest pain at rest, or pain that is new and worsening
  • Breathlessness lying flat, or waking at night gasping
  • Fainting on exertion
  • Sudden tearing back or chest pain

A second opinion is for planned decisions. It is never a substitute for urgent treatment.

Before you submit

Records your reviewer will want

Complete records are the difference between a 48-hour verdict and a week of chasing. Bring what you can — our coordinator tells you what is missing before the clock starts.

  • Angiogram images and report (CD or DICOM)
  • Echocardiogram report, with ejection fraction
  • ECG and any stress test
  • Cardiology consultation notes and the written surgical plan
  • Recent blood work, HbA1c, kidney function

More questions, answered plainly

Browse every panel answer